Friday, June 12, 2015

When Teacher Evaluation is Driven by Bigoted Testing

So today, on the last possible day to administer my End of Year REACH performance task (the test used to check how much I taught students and used to assign me a portion of my rating), I pushed aside our incredible sexual education curriculum to give one of my seventh grade classes the test.

Of course, I was already pretty skeptical of this assessment after last year's fiasco where the 7th grade library test had an extremely racist question in which the test designers made up fictional anti-immigration African American and Latina and forced students to choose one to support.
http://www.wbez.org/news/critics-blast-cps-immigration-test-question-offensive-inaccurate-110232

This was today's test:
https://dochub.com/xianfranzingerbarrett/aXyzER/social-science_grade-7_student_eoy14-15?pg=6

It featured the exact transgender rights principle that I had taught earlier in the week: "People have the right to express their own gender identity and choose how they are addressed". Only the test modeled the bigoted approach:

We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of
interviews w
ith her. We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of
interviews w
ith her. We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of
interviews w
ith her. 
We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of
interviews w
ith her. 
We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of
interviews w
ith her. 
We do not know why Charley Parkhurst chose to live her life as a man, because we have no records of interviews with her.

In fact, the title of the piece was printed on the top of every page:
I was pretty pissed. We've had discussions all week about identity, sexuality and gender, and it took considerable work to create a safe space where students were respectful of the concepts and each other's identification. Now I was administering a test--with my own job rating on the line--which directly violated those concepts.

One of my students raised their hand. "Why does it keep calling 'he' as 'she'"? I said, "Why do you ask?" "It seems like this test doesn't respect Charley's choice."

I said, "That's a great point. You can write that into your answer if you'd like."

The outcomes were incredible. The seventh graders were confused by the conflict of a test enforcing a transphobic narrative and what they knew was fair and right, and this what they came up with in response to the transphobic essay prompt, "Based on teh documents above (A-D), what are the reasons Charley Parker lived her life as a man? Be sure to explain your thinking and use evidence from 304 sources to support your answer."

DC (first crossed out all of the female pronouns and wrote in male ones to respect Charley's choices)
No one can be for sure about this since he hasn't been interviewed. I would say it was by choice and under his circumstances, it would seem relevant. It states in document A that "Another Charley Parkhurst story is that he was the first 'woman' to vote in Colifornia". This might be a reason why he made the transition by his choice. 

MG: The reason Charley Parker changed his gender was because he was a runaway and found his identity in being a male. Both documents A and C have information stating that Charley had family problems and decided to leave home. It also states that Charley loved his life as a male because he had a very important job and was very good at it without being judged by his gender. 

EA:
Charlie Parker (copying the wrong name from the question title) lived his life as a man for a couple of reasons. One of them was because he ran away from the orphanage. Another one was because he enjoyed driving and learning about horses.

JV: Charley Parker lived her life as a man because in Document A, it says that she voted so she was a guy. Also in Document C, Holiday said, "You are just the man I want". So Charley wanted to be a man and also because it was a good choice for her. 

Some of the other students just referred to the subject by his chosen name Charley Parkhurst over and over again to avoid using the incorrect pronouns proscribed by the test. 

Others got confused and thought that since the test was using female pronouns, that must have been Charley's choice, and so deduced that Charley must have been born a man but chose to be a woman because they couldn't believe that the testmakers could be that prejudiced. Others just wrote he/she in every sentence. 

Additionally, I had to help them understand how to connect the documents to the questions as due to the identification of the documents and questions with different alphabet letters, it was hard for them to follow. They knew what primary and secondary sources were, but they couldn't navigate the poor design of the test. My recollection was that the Beginning of Year REACH Performance Task was far shorter and easier than this round--which would destroy the integrity of the growth measurement--but it's no longer available online, so I can't remember for sure. 

In the end, they completed the test, we had a good chat and then they went off to the next class leaving me to input the scores for my rating.

But then the power and water went out at my school and we have no engineering position staffed by the district, so I couldn't put them in anyway. 


28 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi, Great information! Would you please consider sharing my link to your readers? Please email me back at haileyxhailey gmail.com.

    Thanks!
    Hailey

    ReplyDelete
  3. شركة الياسمين تقوم بتنظيف وغسيل الخزانات بجدة كما تقوم ايضا بكشف التسربات وعزل جميع انواع الخزانات
    شركة تنظيف خزانات بجدة
    شركة عزل خزانات بجدة
    شركة كشف تسربات المياه بجدة

    ReplyDelete
  4. Cleaning houses
      Houses are cleaned through
    شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة Anwar city at the highest level of efficiency, development and creativity,
    Where we work with the latest advanced equipment that work with steam, which leads to the elimination of all the dust and dirt and hard spots, and we work on cleaning the canopies and curtains, carpets, rugs and curtains

    ReplyDelete
  5. really cool post, i like your blog, keep going and posting
    فتح ابواب اقفال

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello, everything is going perfectly here and ofcourse every one is sharing data,
    that's truly good, keep up writing.



    토토사이트
    먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete
  7. A good blog always comes-up with new and exciting information and while reading I have feel that this blog is really have all those quality that qualify a blog to be a one. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트

    ReplyDelete
  8. It’s so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, as well as the content! Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트

    ReplyDelete
  10. Very nice blog post. I like this site. Continue the good work! It is exciting to read it and, use it. Thanks for the article. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라

    ReplyDelete
  11. Everything is very open with a really clear explanation of the challenges. It was really informative. Your website is very useful. Many thanks for sharing!
    majortotositepro1
    racesitepro1
    oncasinositenet1
    totopickpro1

    ReplyDelete
  12. 토토사이트
    먹튀검증
    토토365프로


    Your way of explaining everything in this paragraph is actually nice,
    all can simply know it, Thanks a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very nice write-up. I absolutely appreciate this website.
    Keep writing!


    My web-site:

    토토사이트
    토토
    배트맨토토

    ReplyDelete
  14. 스포츠토토


    안전놀이터


    섯다족보
    I want everyone to look around this space. I think I can get the least information. That's the best.

    ReplyDelete